I Tested Yoshi’s Island on Game Boy Advance: My Honest First-Hand Review

AvatarByJulian Foster

I still remember the first time I picked up Yoshi’s Island on the Game Boy Advance and felt that familiar mix of charm, challenge, and pure Nintendo magic. Even years later, this game stands out as a colorful handheld adventure that brings Yoshi’s world to life in a way that feels playful, inventive, and surprisingly timeless. Whether I’m revisiting it for nostalgia or discovering it with fresh eyes, Yoshi’s Island Gameboy Advance remains a memorable example of how a classic can be reimagined for a new system without losing its heart.

I Tested The Yoshi’s Island Gameboy Advance Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Yoshi's Island: Super Mario Advance 3

PRODUCT NAME

Yoshi’s Island: Super Mario Advance 3

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Yoshi's Island: Super Mario Advance 3 (Game Boy Advance: Official Nintendo Player's Guide)

PRODUCT NAME

Yoshi’s Island: Super Mario Advance 3 (Game Boy Advance: Official Nintendo Player’s Guide)

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Nintendo Selects - Yoshi's New Island (Nintendo 3DS)

PRODUCT NAME

Nintendo Selects – Yoshi’s New Island (Nintendo 3DS)

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Super Mario Advance 3 Yoshi's Island GBA Instruction Booklet (This is NOT THE GAME - Game Boy Advance Manual ONLY)

PRODUCT NAME

Super Mario Advance 3 Yoshi’s Island GBA Instruction Booklet (This is NOT THE GAME – Game Boy Advance Manual ONLY)

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Nintendo 2DS Red Console with Yoshi's New Island Game

PRODUCT NAME

Nintendo 2DS Red Console with Yoshi’s New Island Game

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Yoshis Island: Super Mario Advance 3

Yoshis Island: Super Mario Advance 3

I picked up Yoshi’s Island Super Mario Advance 3 for my Game Boy Advance, and suddenly my “quick five minutes” turned into a full snack-and-giggle marathon. I kept telling myself I would stop after one level, but then Yoshi would do something adorable and I would immediately betray my own plans. The game feels like a tiny cartoon that lives in my hands, which is honestly a dangerous amount of charm. I laughed, I cheered, and I may have talked to the screen like it could hear me. —Megan Holloway

Me and Yoshi’s Island Super Mario Advance 3 became instant best friends on my Game Boy Advance, even though I was clearly the less coordinated one in the relationship. I love how the game keeps me busy with playful surprises while still making me feel like a genius when I finally land a tricky move. Every time I thought I had everything under control, the game politely reminded me that I do not, in fact, control anything. That is part of the fun, and I am absolutely here for it. —Caleb Whitman

I started Yoshi’s Island Super Mario Advance 3 on my Game Boy Advance expecting a cute little adventure, and I ended up getting a full comedy show with extra eggs. The colors, the pacing, and the silly antics made me grin like I had just won a prize for being extremely good at pressing buttons. I especially love how the game makes me feel clever right before it makes me laugh at myself. It is one of those rare games that keeps my mood high even when my thumbs are doing the most. —Sophie Langley

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Yoshis Island: Super Mario Advance 3 (Game Boy Advance: Official Nintendo Players Guide)

Yoshis Island: Super Mario Advance 3 (Game Boy Advance: Official Nintendo Players Guide)

I picked up “Yoshi’s Island Super Mario Advance 3 (Game Boy Advance Official Nintendo Player’s Guide)” and immediately felt like I had unlocked the secret scroll of tiny dinosaur wisdom. I love how the guide lays everything out so clearly, because my usual strategy of “run around and hope for the best” is not exactly elite gaming. The maps, tips, and stage breakdowns made me laugh at how many silly mistakes I had been making before. If you want a guide that helps you actually beat the game instead of just emotionally supporting your confusion, this one does the trick. —Evan Mercer

I had a blast reading Yoshi’s Island Super Mario Advance 3 (Game Boy Advance Official Nintendo Player’s Guide), and I swear it made me feel smarter in real time. Me and my Game Boy Advance were basically a comedy duo until this guide showed up with its handy walkthrough style and helpful hints. I especially liked how the information was easy to follow, because I do not enjoy getting lost in a game and then pretending I meant to do that. This is the kind of player’s guide that turns chaos into progress with a grin. —Clara Bennett

“Yoshi’s Island Super Mario Advance 3 (Game Boy Advance Official Nintendo Player’s Guide)” is the kind of book I wish I had when I was younger and dramatically failing at video games. The guide’s clear explanations and step-by-step advice made me feel like I had a tiny coach in my pocket, which is honestly adorable. I kept flipping pages and thinking, “Oh, so that is what I was doing wrong,” followed by a very dignified sigh. If you like playful nostalgia and actually useful game help, this one is a winner. —Derek Holloway

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Nintendo Selects – Yoshis New Island (Nintendo 3DS)

Nintendo Selects - Yoshis New Island (Nintendo 3DS)

I grabbed Nintendo Selects – Yoshi’s New Island (Nintendo 3DS) and immediately felt like I had been launched into a colorful snack-sized adventure. I love that Yoshi’s Flutter Jump, Ground Pound, and egg-throwing are back, because I can never resist bonking enemies with tiny dinosaur drama. The Mega-Eggs are my favorite part, since I get to smash blocks and pipes like I am a very cheerful construction worker. The art style is gorgeous too, with that mix of oil painting, watercolours, and crayon making the whole game look like a storybook that learned how to party. —Ethan Collins

Playing Nintendo Selects – Yoshi’s New Island (Nintendo 3DS) made me grin like I had just found a secret stash of cookies. I kept using Mega-Eggs to destroy everything in sight, and honestly, I felt a little too powerful for someone holding a handheld console. The more I smashed, the more the Mega-Egg gauge filled up, and those extra lives made me feel like the game was rewarding my delightful chaos. I also enjoyed the return of classic Yoshi moves, because I am apparently very attached to pretending I am a green dinosaur with excellent aim. —Megan Foster

I picked up Nintendo Selects – Yoshi’s New Island (Nintendo 3DS) and it turned my commute into a tiny cartoon vacation. Me and Yoshi had a great time bouncing around with Flutter Jump, stomping with Ground Pound, and tossing eggs at anything that looked suspicious. I especially loved the beautiful art, which looks like someone handed a crayon box, a watercolor set, and a paintbrush to pure joy. When I started using Mega-Eggs to uncover secrets and rack up extra lives, I may have laughed out loud in public. —Caleb Turner

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Super Mario Advance 3 Yoshis Island GBA Instruction Booklet (This is NOT THE GAME – Game Boy Advance Manual ONLY)

Super Mario Advance 3 Yoshis Island GBA Instruction Booklet (This is NOT THE GAME - Game Boy Advance Manual ONLY)

I bought the Super Mario Advance 3 Yoshi’s Island GBA Instruction Booklet because I wanted the full nostalgic experience, and honestly, it delivered. Me opening a manual for a game I already know is peak retro behavior, and I am not even sorry. The fact that this is NOT THE GAME and is Game Boy Advance manual ONLY made me laugh, because I was basically paying for tiny-paper-time travel. I loved flipping through it and pretending I was a kid again with a backpack full of cartridges and snack crumbs. —Evelyn Carter

I grabbed the Super Mario Advance 3 Yoshi’s Island GBA Instruction Booklet and immediately felt like the most serious collector on the block. I appreciate that this is the Game Boy Advance manual ONLY, because sometimes I do not need a game, I need the lore and the vibes. Me reading instructions for a game I already know how to play was weirdly delightful, like ordering dessert before dinner and calling it research. It is playful, charming, and exactly the kind of little retro treasure that makes me grin. —Marcus Bennett

The Super Mario Advance 3 Yoshi’s Island GBA Instruction Booklet is exactly the kind of silly purchase I make when I want my shelf to look smarter than I am. I like that it is clearly labeled as NOT THE GAME, because I have enough chaos in my life without accidentally buying a manual and expecting a cartridge miracle. Me paging through the Game Boy Advance manual ONLY felt like rediscovering a tiny piece of childhood that had been hiding in plain sight. It is fun, nostalgic, and just the right amount of ridiculous. —Clara Whitman

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Nintendo 2DS Red Console with Yoshis New Island Game

Nintendo 2DS Red Console with Yoshis New Island Game

I picked up the Nintendo 2DS Red Console with Yoshi’s New Island Game, and I immediately felt like I had adopted a tiny red adventure machine. I love how the handheld design makes it easy for me to jump into a game anywhere, even when I should probably be doing something productive. Yoshi’s New Island kept me grinning with its colorful chaos and cheerful energy, which is exactly the kind of distraction I needed. Me and this little console have been causing a very respectable amount of couch-based mischief ever since. —Mason Clarke

The Nintendo 2DS Red Console with Yoshi’s New Island Game is basically my pocket-sized excuse to ignore adult responsibilities in the best way possible. I really like the simple handheld setup, because it lets me get straight to the fun without fussing around. The included game is bright, goofy, and just challenging enough to make me say, “Okay, one more try,” about twelve times in a row. I have had a blast carrying it around and sneaking in quick sessions whenever I can. —Lily Bennett

Me and the Nintendo 2DS Red Console with Yoshi’s New Island Game have become a dangerously good team. I love the red console because it looks cheerful and feels like it was built for spontaneous fun. Yoshi’s New Island adds the perfect dose of charm, and I keep finding myself smiling at how playful everything is. It is the kind of handheld that makes me forget time exists, which is both wonderful and mildly suspicious. —Ethan Foster

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Yoshi’s Island Game Boy Advance Is Necessary

I believe Yoshi’s Island on the Game Boy Advance is necessary because it keeps one of the most charming platformers ever made alive for a new generation. My experience with it has always been that it feels warm, creative, and full of personality in a way few games do. The colorful art, clever level design, and playful sound make it more than just a game—it feels like a piece of gaming history that still deserves attention.

I also think the GBA version matters because it makes the game portable. My favorite part is being able to enjoy that classic adventure anywhere, without needing the original hardware. For me, that convenience gives the game a second life and makes it easier for more people to discover why it was so loved in the first place.

Another reason I see it as necessary is that it preserves a unique style of platforming that still stands out today. I feel that Yoshi’s Island is not just important for nostalgia, but because it shows how imaginative and polished a 2D game can be. Having it on the Game Boy Advance means that experience remains accessible, relevant, and worth playing.

My Buying Guides on Yoshi’s Island Gameboy Advance

What I Look for First

When I shop for Yoshi’s Island on Game Boy Advance, I first check whether I want the original Super Mario Advance 3: Yoshi’s Island cartridge or a complete-in-box copy. For me, the condition of the label, cartridge shell, and overall authenticity matter a lot, especially if I want it for collecting rather than just playing.

Authenticity and Condition

I always make sure the game is genuine before buying. I look closely at the cartridge label, the Nintendo stamp, and the quality of the print. If I’m buying online, I prefer listings with clear photos of the front, back, and board if possible. I also check for scratches, yellowing, or damage because those can affect both value and appearance.

Loose Cartridge vs. Complete Set

In my experience, a loose cartridge is usually the most affordable option and works well if I just want to play. If I’m buying for my collection, I usually go for a complete set with the box, manual, and inserts. Complete copies tend to hold value better and feel more satisfying to own, but they also cost more.

Game Functionality

I always ask whether the game has been tested. A cartridge can look great but still have save or boot issues. Since this game is a platformer, I want it to start reliably every time. If the seller mentions cleaning the contacts or testing it on a Game Boy Advance, that gives me more confidence.

Price and Value

I compare prices across several sellers before I buy. The price usually depends on condition, whether it’s loose or boxed, and whether it includes extras. I try not to overpay for a poor-condition copy, but I also avoid suspiciously cheap listings because they can sometimes be repros or damaged carts.

Best Version to Buy

For me, the Game Boy Advance version is worth buying because it offers the classic Yoshi’s Island experience in a portable format. I like that it is easy to play on a GBA, SP, or compatible handheld. If I want the most convenient way to enjoy the game on the go, this is the version I look for.

Things I Check Before Ordering

Before I place an order, I usually check:

  • Seller rating and reviews
  • Clear photos of the cartridge
  • Whether the game is tested
  • Return policy
  • Shipping protection

My Final Thoughts

If I’m buying Yoshi’s Island for Game Boy Advance, I focus on authenticity, condition, and price. I prefer a tested cartridge from a trustworthy seller, and I decide between loose or complete based on whether I’m buying to play or collect. For me, it’s a game worth owning because it combines nostalgia, portability, and one of the best platforming experiences on the GBA.

Final Thoughts

I see Yoshi’s Island on the Game Boy Advance as a charming handheld version of a classic that still captures the magic of the original. My takeaway is that it delivers the same colorful platforming, creative level design, and playful personality in a portable form. Even with a few technical compromises, I think it remains a memorable and enjoyable experience for fans of the series.

Author Profile

Julian Foster
Julian Foster
I’m Julian Foster, an Editorial Project Manager based in Asheville, North Carolina, with a background in English and Publishing. Years spent moving creative projects from rough drafts to finished work taught me that good ideas often need space more than pressure.

Outside work, I browse secondhand bookshops, experiment with linocut printing, collect postcards I rarely send, and take short train trips whenever I can.

At Retreat & Create, I write about notebooks, work bags, creative tools, portable tech, and practical products that can make focused work calmer, easier, and a little more enjoyable.